10 Best Meal Delivery Services (2024) | Tested by a Chef
Discover the 10 best meal delivery services tested by an ex-restaurant critic. Compare prices, prep times, and diets to find your perfect meal kit today!
The 10 Best Meal Delivery Services, Tested by an Ex-Restaurant Critic
The world of meal delivery services is a minefield. One minute you are promised gourmet meals delivered to your door, the next you are staring at a box of wilted greens and a recipe that requires a degree in molecular gastronomy. As someone who has spent more time than I care to admit in professional kitchens—and testing every kitchen gadget that hits the market—I am here to cut through the noise. This is not just about convenience; it is about reclaiming your evenings and elevating your home cooking without the soul-crushing dread of a grocery store run on a Tuesday night.
I have spent months putting these services through the ringer, looking for the same things I looked for in a five-star restaurant: ingredient integrity, technical clarity, and that elusive wow factor. Here are the ten services that actually earned their spot on my counter.
QUICK COMPARISON SNAPSHOT
HelloFresh: 10.00 dollars per serving | 30-45 mins prep | Classic Variety
EveryPlate: 5.00 to 7.00 dollars per serving | 20-30 mins prep | Budget Friendly
Green Chef: 13.00 dollars per serving | 30 mins prep | Keto, Paleo, Organic
Martha Stewart & Marley Spoon: 11.00 dollars per serving | 30-40 mins prep | Gourmet Technique
Sunbasket: 12.00 to 15.00 dollars per serving | 15-35 mins prep | Organic and Sustainable
Blue Apron: 10.00 to 12.00 dollars per serving | 45 mins prep | Culinary Education
Home Chef: 10.00 dollars per serving | 15-40 mins prep | High Customization
Factor: 11.00 to 14.00 dollars per serving | 2 mins prep | Fully Prepared
Purple Carrot: 13.00 dollars per serving | 30 mins prep | 100 percent Plant-Based
Daily Harvest: 7.00 to 12.00 dollars per item | 5 mins prep | Smoothies and Grains
THE CULINARY EXPLORER: MARTHA STEWART AND MARLEY SPOON
If you want to expand your repertoire and appreciate high-quality ingredients, this is the gold standard. This service leans into classic, elevated recipes that often have a unique twist. You will find well-tested dishes that feel special without requiring a sous-chef to help with the prep.
The Standout Dish: The Braised Beef Gnocchi with Brown Butter and Sage was restaurant-quality. The depth of flavor in the sauce suggested hours of simmering, yet it came together in forty minutes.
Gift This To: The in-law who loves to host dinner parties but complains about never having enough time to prep.
About Team Gimmie
A small team of friends and colleagues working together to produce useful content to help you...gift better.
THE BUDGET-CONSCIOUS CHAMPION: EVERYPLATE
Not everyone wants to drop a significant chunk of change on a meal kit every week. EveryPlate consistently shows up as the most affordable option without sacrificing flavor. The recipes are simpler, often featuring familiar comfort foods, which makes them quick to prepare.
The Standout Dish: The Pork Sausage and Bell Pepper Pasta was a surprising winner. It relied on high-quality fat and simple seasoning rather than expensive garnishes.
Gift This To: The recent college grad who is currently surviving on cereal and instant noodles.
THE HEALTH-FOCUSED PICK: GREEN CHEF
Green Chef is for the person who treats their body like a temple but does not have the time to source organic turmeric and pre-cut jicama. They offer plans tailored to Keto, Paleo, and Mediterranean diets, with a heavy emphasis on organic produce.
The Standout Dish: The Barramundi with Roasted Red Pepper Sauce and Zucchini Noodles was light, vibrant, and perfectly balanced. The fish stayed flaky, and the sauce had a professional-grade acid balance.
Gift This To: The sibling who just joined a CrossFit gym and talks exclusively about their macros.
THE NO-FUSS STAR: HELLOFRESH
There is a reason HelloFresh is the giant in the room. Their interface is intuitive, and their recipe cards are the clearest in the business. It is a reliable choice for busy weeknights when you have exactly zero brainpower left for decision-making.
The Standout Dish: Their Firecracker Meatballs are a cult favorite for a reason. The ginger-soy glaze has just enough kick to keep things interesting.
Gift This To: The busy new parents who barely have time to sleep, let alone plan a menu.
THE FAMILY FAVORITE: HOME CHEF
Home Chef strikes a balance between variety and family-friendliness. They offer customizable options, allowing you to swap proteins or sides—a huge plus when you have picky eaters at the table.
The Standout Dish: The Crispy Parmesan Chicken with Lemon Asparagus is a crowd-pleaser that even kids won't argue with. It is simple, effective, and hits all the right comfort notes.
Gift This To: The household with three kids and a very narrow window for dinner.
THE ECO-CONSCIOUS GOURMET: SUNBASKET
Sunbasket feels like a trip to a high-end California farmers market. Their commitment to sustainability and organic ingredients is unmatched, and their flavor profiles lean toward the global and adventurous.
The Standout Dish: The Shrimp Paella with Chorizo and Fire-Roasted Peppers felt like something I would order at a tapas bar. The ingredients were incredibly fresh.
Gift This To: Your cousin who shops exclusively at the local co-op and owns a compost bin.
THE CULINARY CLASSIC: BLUE APRON
Blue Apron is the original player, and they have stayed relevant by focusing on the craft of cooking. Their recipes often include a "technique" section that teaches you how to properly mince, sear, or deglaze.
The Standout Dish: The Seared Steaks with Peppercorn Sauce and Roasted Potatoes is a masterclass in the basics. It teaches you how to build a pan sauce that rivals a French bistro.
Gift This To: The couple looking for a "date night" activity that does not involve Netflix.
THE TIME-SAVER: FACTOR
Factor is not a "kit" in the traditional sense; it is a heat-and-eat service. However, unlike the frozen dinners of the past, these meals are fresh, never frozen, and designed by dietitians.
The Standout Dish: The Jalapeno Lime Cheddar Chicken is genuinely delicious and surprisingly moist for a pre-cooked meal. It takes exactly two minutes in the microwave.
Gift This To: The workaholic friend who thinks a handful of almonds counts as a balanced lunch.
THE PLANT-BASED PIONEER: PURPLE CARROT
Vegan food often gets a bad rap for being boring, but Purple Carrot proves that plants can be the star of the show. They use clever techniques to create texture and depth without any animal products.
The Standout Dish: The Peanut Noodles with Seared Tofu and Bok Choy. The sear on the tofu was excellent, and the sauce had a complex, nutty heat.
Gift This To: The friend who is "vegan-curious" but does not know what to do with a head of cauliflower.
THE WELLNESS JUNKIE: DAILY HARVEST
Daily Harvest specializes in frozen, plant-based smoothies, harvest bowls, and flatbreads. Everything is pre-portioned and requires minimal effort—usually just adding water or milk and blending or heating.
The Standout Dish: The Dragon Fruit and Lychee Smoothie is refreshing, vibrant, and packed with antioxidants. It is the easiest breakfast on this list.
Gift This To: The person who is always on the go and needs a healthy hit of nutrients before a morning meeting.
WHAT TO CONSIDER BEFORE YOU SUBSCRIBE
Before you commit, keep a few things in mind. First, check the portion sizes. Some services are generous, while others assume you have the appetite of a small bird. If you like leftovers for lunch, always order for an extra person.
Second, consider the packaging. The amount of cardboard and plastic can be overwhelming. While companies like Sunbasket use recyclable liners, it is still a lot to manage. If you live in an apartment with limited recycling, factor this into your choice.
Finally, look at flexibility. Life happens. You want a service that makes it easy to skip a week or pause your subscription without jumping through hoops. Most of these services allow you to manage everything through an app, which is a lifesaver.
THE VERDICT: IS A MEAL KIT RIGHT FOR YOU?
Meal delivery services have evolved from a novelty into a legitimate lifestyle tool. Whether you are a seasoned chef looking for inspiration or a novice who just learned how to boil water, there is a kit on this list that will make your life better.
My advice? Start with the service that aligns with your biggest pain point. If it is money, go with EveryPlate. If it is time, go with Factor. If it is a lack of inspiration, Martha Stewart is waiting for you. Take advantage of those introductory offers, get in the kitchen, and remember: even the best chefs started with a recipe and a box.
10 Best Meal Delivery Services (2024) | Tested by a Chef | Gimmie
